We Researched the Best Vinyl Siding Brands So You Don’t Have To

Why Choosing the Right Vinyl Siding Matters

When searching for the best vinyl siding companies, you’re looking to protect your biggest investment and improve your home’s appearance. Siding shields your house from wind, rain, and extreme temperatures, lowers energy costs, and can significantly boost property value. Here are top brands to consider for your Ohio home:

Top 5 Vinyl Siding Brands:

1. CertainTeed – Industry leader, widest color selection ($5-$9/sq ft)
2. Alside – Strong warranties, great storm protection ($3-$7.50/sq ft)
3. Ply Gem – Sustainable, up to 80% recycled content ($6-$15/sq ft)
4. Royal Building Products – Best value, ENERGY STAR certified ($2-$7/sq ft)
5. Kaycan – Superior fade resistance for warm climates ($3-$8/sq ft)

However, not all vinyl siding is created equal. Some brands fade under the Ohio sun or crack in harsh winters. The wrong choice can lead to costly repairs. Fortunately, today’s leading manufacturers offer products that truly perform. Modern vinyl siding resists chipping, peeling, and fading far better than older products.

Installation matters just as much as the brand you choose. Even the best siding won’t perform if installed incorrectly, leading to moisture intrusion, warping, and voided warranties. Professional installation adds $3 to $10 per square foot but ensures your siding lasts for decades.

I’m Shawn Zeisler, of Kyline Construction LLC in Circleville, Ohio. With decades of hands-on experience installing and repairing siding from every major manufacturer, I’ve seen which brands and installation practices deliver long-term performance.

Our Top Picks: A Guide to the Best Vinyl Siding Companies & Brands

Choosing new siding for your home in Columbus or Circleville, Ohio, can feel like a big decision. We’ve sifted through the market’s leading brands to bring you a curated list of the best vinyl siding companies that offer quality, durability, and style. For a deeper dive into expert opinions, you can also check out this list of the best vinyl siding brands by BobVila.com.

Here’s a closer look at our top picks, detailing what makes each one stand out:

CertainTeed

An industry leader since 1904, CertainTeed offers an exceptional selection of polymer, insulated, and traditional vinyl siding. They boast one of the widest, most fade-resistant color palettes available. Their products are approved by the National Green Building Standards (NGBS) for energy efficiency and green materials.

• Key Features & Benefits: Cedar Impressions® Polymer Shakes mimic milled cedar without the maintenance. CedarBoards™ Insulated Siding improves energy efficiency and reduces noise with its foam backing.
• Typical Price Range: $5.00 – $9.00 per sq. ft.
• Pros: Exceptional durability, extensive color and style range, high-quality reputation, and a Lifetime Limited Warranty. NGBS approval is a plus for eco-conscious homeowners.
• Cons: Generally pricier than competitors. Some specialized products require specific installation techniques.

Alside

With over 75 years of expertise, Ohio-based Alside is a versatile choice for local homeowners, offering traditional vinyl, insulated vinyl, and robust steel siding. They were recently named a 2024 Brand Survey Winner by Builder and Developer.

• Key Features & Benefits: Alside’s Prodigy® insulated siding is one of the industry’s thickest, offering superior insulation and energy efficiency. Their Charter Oak® line provides the beauty of wood with exceptional durability. For extreme weather, their steel siding withstands hurricane-force winds and includes a 50-year hail damage warranty.
• Typical Price Range: $3.00 – $7.50 per sq. ft.
• Pros: Strong warranties, especially the 50-year hail damage warranty on steel siding, make it great for storm protection. Their products are recognized for environmental benefits and require minimal maintenance.
• Cons: Potential for color consistency issues across different batches. Durability can vary between product lines.

Ply Gem

Ply Gem stands out for its commitment to sustainability. Their siding products contain up to 80% recycled material, making them a great choice for eco-conscious homeowners in Ohio.

• Key Features & Benefits: Ply Gem offers a wide range of low-maintenance vinyl siding styles and textures. Their Mastic siding line, composed of 80% recycled materials, blends durability with aesthetic appeal.
• Typical Price Range: $6.00 – $15.00 per sq. ft. (specialty options may be higher).
• Pros: Highly sustainable due to significant recycled content. They offer a comprehensive suite of siding options, from traditional to specialty styles.
• Cons: Specialty options can be expensive. Occasional reports of panel warping, which can be linked to improper installation.

Royal Building Products

A significant player since 1970, Royal Building Products offers a blend of value, durability, and a comprehensive warranty. They provide high-quality vinyl siding that mimics natural materials without the high maintenance.

• Key Features & Benefits: Royal offers ENERGY STAR certified products to improve energy efficiency. Their Chromatix™ technology provides superior UV resistance, preserving vibrant colors.
• Typical Price Range: $2.00 – $7.00 per sq. ft.
• Pros: Excellent value with durable products and a comprehensive warranty. ENERGY STAR certification is a major benefit for Ohio homeowners.
• Cons: Potential for brittleness in extreme cold, which is a consideration for Ohio winters. Less brand recognition than some larger players.

Kaycan

A global player since the mid-1970s, Kaycan is recognized for innovative technology and sustainability. Their solutions are designed to withstand harsh weather, making them a strong contender for Ohio homes.

• Key Features & Benefits: HELIOS™ technology ensures resilience against harsh sun, while impact modifiers protect siding in freezing temperatures, perfect for Ohio winters. Kaycan leads in sustainability with its R3V program, which reclaims and repurposes used vinyl. Their warranty includes a 25-year fade resistance guarantee.
• Typical Price Range: $3.00 – $8.00 per sq. ft.
• Pros: Exceptional heat and cold resistance makes it ideal for Ohio’s climate. Strong 25-year fade resistance warranty and robust sustainability practices (99% of materials are recyclable). You can use their design tool to visualize your home with their products.
• Cons: Distribution may be more limited, and they may offer fewer color and style options than some competitors.

Georgia-Pacific

Founded in 1927, Georgia-Pacific specializes in vinyl siding and is exclusively distributed by BlueLinx. They offer a variety of styles to meet diverse homeowner needs, making them a reliable choice for Ohio.

• Key Features & Benefits: Georgia-Pacific offers lap, shake, shingle, and vertical siding styles. Their products feature high-grade UV protectants for color stability and are virtually maintenance-free. They also offer an interactive design tool.
• Typical Price Range: $2.50 – $5.00 per sq. ft.
• Pros: An affordable, budget-friendly option. Good color variety and wide availability. Designed for durability and low maintenance.
• Cons: Some lines may be less robust in extreme weather. Potential for moisture absorption if not installed perfectly, and quality control can be inconsistent.

How to Choose the Right Siding for Your Home

Choosing new siding is a significant investment, and it’s important to consider various factors to ensure you make the best decision for your Ohio home. Let’s dig into what truly matters when evaluating the best vinyl siding companies and their offerings.

Key Factors When Choosing Among the Best Vinyl Siding Companies

When selecting siding for your Ohio home, we emphasize these critical factors:

• Durability: Essential for Ohio’s varied weather. Look for siding that withstands summer storms and winter freezes, often featuring impact modifiers and robust construction.
• Weather Resistance: Consider how well siding resists moisture, UV radiation, and temperature changes. Brands like Kaycan and Alside offer options engineered for superior weather performance.
• Wind Ratings: In areas with high winds, look for strong wind resistance ratings (some products withstand over 190 mph), achieved through features like double-thick nail hems.
• R-value for Energy Efficiency: Insulated vinyl siding (e.g., CertainTeed’s CedarBoards™) has a higher R-value, providing better insulation and reducing energy costs.
• Maintenance Requirements: Vinyl siding is appealing for its low maintenance, as it resists chipping, peeling, and fading. Most types only require occasional cleaning.
• Climate Suitability: Specific features make a brand better for Ohio. Kaycan’s cold-weather resilience or Alside’s hail damage warranty are key differentiators.
• Home Architecture: Your home’s style should guide your choice. Vinyl siding comes in various profiles (lap, board and batten, shakes) and colors to complement any design.
• Budget: Costs vary widely. We work with clients to find a solution that meets their performance needs and budget.

Decoding Siding Warranties

A warranty is a promise of quality and a safeguard for your investment. Understanding the nuances of siding warranties from the best vinyl siding companies is crucial:

• Limited Lifetime Warranty: Common for top brands (e.g., CertainTeed, Kaycan), this typically covers manufacturing defects for the original homeowner’s lifetime in the home.
• Prorated vs. Non-Prorated: A non-prorated warranty covers 100% of replacement costs for the warranty period, while prorated coverage decreases over time. Aim for non-prorated when possible.
• Fade Resistance Coverage: This is important for sunny Ohio. Kaycan, for instance, offers a 25-year fade resistance warranty. Look for clear statements on how color fading is covered.
• Hail and Storm Damage Clauses: Given Ohio’s weather, specific coverage for hail is invaluable. Alside’s 50-year hail damage warranty on its steel siding is an excellent example. Read the fine print to understand what’s covered.
• Transferability for Resale Value: A transferable warranty can be a significant selling point, allowing subsequent owners to benefit from the remaining coverage and adding peace of mind for buyers.

Latest Trends in Siding Styles and Colors

Home exteriors have trends, and homeowners in Ohio are embracing some exciting new directions with their siding choices:

• Bold Dark Colors: Dark, moody colors like navy blue, charcoal gray, and deep forest green are surging in popularity. Brands like Royal Building Products use technologies like Chromatix™ to ensure these dark hues stay vibrant.
• Wood-Look Textures: Vinyl siding has evolved to flawlessly mimic the textures of cedar shingles or wood lap siding, offering a classic look with easy maintenance.
• Vertical Siding and Board & Batten: Moving beyond horizontal panels, vertical and board and batten styles are gaining traction. This creates visual interest and can give a home a modern farmhouse feel.
• Mixed Materials: Combining vinyl siding with other materials like stone veneer or brick creates a custom, high-end look and adds depth to your home’s exterior.
• Sustainable and Recycled Materials: Homeowners are increasingly interested in sustainable options. Brands like Ply Gem and Kaycan lead the way with high recycled content and recycling programs.

From Material to Installation: Understanding the Total Cost

When budgeting for new siding, it’s easy to focus solely on the material cost. However, we always advise our clients in Ohio to consider the entire picture, from removal to installation, to get an accurate understanding of the total investment. The overall expense is a combination of materials, labor, and any necessary preparatory work.

Understanding Costs from the Best Vinyl Siding Companies

The material cost for vinyl siding can vary widely based on the brand, quality, thickness, and style you choose. Here’s a general comparison of average material costs per square foot for our top picks:

• Material Costs: As you can see from the table, there’s a significant range. Premium insulated vinyl siding or specialized polymer shakes will naturally cost more than standard vinyl panels. Factors like color vibrancy, fade resistance technology, and thickness (e.g., .046″ or higher for improved durability) all play a role in the material price.
• Installation and Labor Costs: This is often the largest portion of the total project cost. Across the industry, installation and labor typically range from $3 to $10 per square foot, averaging around $6.50 per square foot. This includes the skill and time required for proper measuring, cutting, fastening, and finishing.
• Cost to Remove Old Siding: If you’re replacing existing siding, there will be a cost associated with its removal and disposal. This generally ranges from $1,000 to $2,000, depending on the size of your home and the type of old material.
• Soffit, Fascia, and Trim Costs: Don’t forget these crucial finishing touches! Soffit, fascia, and trim not only improve your home’s curb appeal but also play vital roles in ventilation and protecting vulnerable areas. These components are typically priced separately and add to the overall project cost.

Why Professional Installation is Crucial

We cannot stress this enough: the quality of the installation is just as important as the quality of the siding itself. Even if you choose the best vinyl siding from a top-tier company, improper installation can lead to a host of problems and negate the benefits of your investment. This is where experienced professionals like us at Kyline Construction LLC come in.

• Ensures Warranty Validity: Most manufacturers’ warranties are contingent on proper installation according to their specifications. DIY or shoddy installation can void your warranty, leaving you unprotected if issues arise.
• Prevents Moisture Intrusion: Correct installation involves meticulous attention to detail with house wrap, flashing, and sealing. This creates a watertight barrier, preventing moisture from getting behind your siding, which can lead to rot, mold, and structural damage.
• Maximizes Energy Efficiency: Properly installed siding, especially insulated options, creates an effective thermal barrier. This reduces air leakage and helps maintain consistent indoor temperatures, leading to lower energy bills for your Ohio home.
• Proper Handling of House Wrap and Flashing: These are critical components of your home’s weather barrier. Professionals understand how to correctly apply house wrap and install flashing around windows, doors, and other openings to ensure maximum protection.
• Avoids Common Issues: Incorrectly installed vinyl siding can warp, buckle, or sag. Our experienced team knows the nuances of vinyl’s expansion and contraction, ensuring panels are installed with the necessary clearances to prevent these unsightly and damaging problems.

For all your siding needs, trust the experts. Learn more about Our Vinyl Siding Services and how we ensure a flawless finish for your home.

Frequently Asked Questions About Vinyl Siding

We often hear similar questions from homeowners in Circleville and Columbus, Ohio, when they’re considering new vinyl siding. Let’s tackle some of the most common ones.

How do I know if my siding needs to be replaced?

Over time, siding shows signs of wear. Here are key indicators that it’s time for a replacement:

• Visible Damage: Cracks, holes, or warping compromise your home’s protection.
• Bubbling or Blistering: On painted siding, this indicates trapped moisture.
• Rot or Crumbling: A serious sign of moisture damage, especially on wood siding.
• Mold or Mildew: Persistent growth suggests moisture retention issues.
• Faded Color: Older or lower-quality vinyl can fade, making your home look dated.
• Increased Energy Bills: Deteriorating siding can cause gaps and cracks, leading to energy loss.
• Interior Wall Damage: Peeling paint or mold inside can mean moisture is penetrating your siding.

What is the most durable type of vinyl siding?

Several factors contribute to vinyl siding’s durability against impacts and harsh weather:

• Insulated Vinyl Siding: Siding with a rigid foam backing (like CertainTeed’s CedarBoards™) offers superior impact resistance and energy efficiency. The foam backing prevents dents from hail or other objects.
• Thicker Panels: Standard siding is .040″-.042″ thick, but premium panels (.046″ or higher) provide greater rigidity and resistance to warping.
• Advanced Lock Systems: For high wind resistance, look for features like a double nail hem and secure panel locks. Some brands are verified to withstand winds over 190 MPH, crucial for preventing blow-offs in severe storms.

Is vinyl siding a sustainable choice?

Many of the best vinyl siding companies are improving their environmental footprint, making vinyl an increasingly sustainable choice.

• Recycled Materials: Brands like Ply Gem incorporate up to 80% recycled content, reducing the demand for new resources.
• Recycling Programs: Companies like Kaycan have programs (R3V) to reclaim and repurpose used vinyl, diverting it from landfills. Over 99% of Kaycan’s materials are recyclable.
• Energy Efficiency: Insulated vinyl siding boosts a home’s thermal performance, lowering the carbon footprint by reducing heating and cooling needs. Look for NGBS-approved products.
• Longevity and Low Maintenance: Vinyl siding lasts for decades and requires no painting or staining, which reduces the use of chemicals over the home’s life.

While vinyl (PVC) is non-biodegradable, these advancements in recycling and energy efficiency make it a more responsible choice.

Conclusion: Partnering with the Right Experts for a Flawless Finish

Choosing the right vinyl siding brand for your home in Circleville or Columbus, Ohio, is a critical first step, but it’s only half the battle. The quality of the installation ultimately determines the performance, longevity, and aesthetic appeal of your investment. A beautiful, durable product from one of the best vinyl siding companies can fall short if not installed with precision and care.

That’s why partnering with experienced professionals who understand local building codes and manufacturer specifications is paramount. Proper installation ensures your siding performs as intended, protecting your home from the elements, maximizing energy efficiency, and preserving your warranty.

At Kyline Construction LLC, we pride ourselves on our commitment to quality, safety, and customer satisfaction. With over 40 years of experience in the industry, our team of seasoned professionals ensures your siding project is handled with the utmost precision and care. We’ve seen what works and what doesn’t in Ohio’s climate, and we bring that expertise to every job.

Don’t leave your biggest investment to chance. Contact us today for a free, no-obligation estimate on your siding project! Let us help you transform your home with a flawless finish that will last for decades.